Skip to the page
Sniff, Purr, Preen & Shoal

You are the habitat.

At floor level: a term this site uses

The Hand-Me-Down Rule

Revised

The hand-me-down rule is what Sniff, Purr, Preen & Shoal calls a rule of thumb that passes from owner to owner, or hobbyist to hobbyist, without a source anyone can point to.

Four steps

A page that meets a hand-me-down rule checks it in the same order every time:

  1. Earliest source. Find the oldest printed or recorded statement of the rule that can be named and dated. If none turns up, the page says so.
  2. Mechanism. Ask what would have to be true for the rule to work, and whether any study supports it.
  3. Counterexamples. Look for measurements or cases the rule gets wrong.
  4. Verdict. Keep the rule, rewrite it into something the evidence supports, or retire it.

The verdict and the evidence behind it are stated on the page, and a later change of verdict is logged as a correction.

Rules on the bench

Rules this site has checked so far, each on its own page: seven human years for every dog year, the three-second goldfish memory, one inch of fish per gallon of water, the bell in Pavlov's laboratory, a purr as the sign of a contented cat, a dog's nose as 10,000 to 100,000 times a human's and a fixed "times better" figure for a cat's eyes in the dark. The dog-year rule, for example, is set against a 2020 study that compared DNA methylation in dogs and people and matched a 1-year-old dog with a human of about 31.

What the label does not mean

Calling something a hand-me-down rule describes how it travels, not whether it is wrong. Some survive the four steps. A rule about animal care is never replaced with a new prescription; where health is involved, the question goes to a veterinarian. The site's sources and reading levels are explained in Sniff test.